You own a home in Babcock Ranch and you are thinking about selling. Or you are buying and weighing a resale against a new build. Either way, you want to know what the market is really doing.

This episode is built on data rather than opinions. John Garuti, Greg and Susan, who works in mortgage lending, go through the National Association of Realtors generational report, then the Babcock Ranch resale numbers after a record first quarter for new home sales. This is a video post with the full transcript below.

Why do 43% of buyers choose a new home over a resale?

The first stat in the report stands out. 43% of recent buyers chose a new home to avoid renovations and problems with plumbing or electricity. Southwest Florida is loaded with new construction, so this hits our market directly. Our advice to sellers: get an inspection before you list. It is always cheaper to fix things first than to negotiate them later. We just saw a deal fall apart over about $500 of repairs. Buyers pick previously owned homes for better overall value or a better price. As we say, you either have a deal or a diamond. If it is not a diamond, price decides.

Does impact glass change what a Babcock Ranch resale sells for?

Buyers in the report ranked heating and cooling costs, windows and doors as their most important environmental features. In Babcock Ranch that shows up as impact glass. A home without it will likely sell for less than a similar home with it, even when the non-impact home has more upgrades inside. Your house is still fine in a hurricane with the shutters up, but this perceived value is real money at closing, and almost every new home now has impact glass as standard. The report also says the typical home bought is around 1,900 to 2,000 square feet with three bedrooms and two baths. Buyers shop by beds, baths and cost per square foot, not floor plan name, so the heaviest competition sits between 1,800 and 2,100 square feet.

What are buyers and lenders doing with financing right now?

About 74% of buyers finance their purchase, so roughly one in four pays cash. Here, cash buyers cluster on the golf course condos. Single-family buyers mostly use a mortgage, and most now ask for closing cost help, so sellers should focus on their net. Susan's tip for cash buyers: buy with cash to win the negotiation, then use delayed financing to pull some of it back out as a small loan. The top reason lenders reject an application is debt to income ratio. Susan explains the front end ratio (mortgage payment, taxes, insurance and homeowners association dues) and the back end ratio, which adds car payments and other debts. Conventional loans top out around 50%. She would like to see buyers under 45%. For the monthly dues here, use the HOA calculator.

What is the Babcock Ranch resale market doing right now?

We look at resales only, because the builders do not enter most of their sales in the MLS. Around 390 new homes sold in the first quarter, a record for the town. There are 100 active resale listings against more than 5,500 finished properties: 39 single-family homes, 37 villas and the rest condos. Sold single-family homes skew higher than many expect. Only one sold in the 300s, while eight sold in the 600s and three over $800,000. The lower range is where you compete with the builders; Tucker's Cove alone holds around 40 homes there. 25 single-family listings were terminated or expired, close to one in three. Average days on market is about 75. Greg estimates that 90% of buyers here choose new construction, and 60% of those never use a realtor, so they never see your listing.

Where is the Babcock Ranch market heading?

The country has had three straight years of the worst home sales in about 50 years. The last 12 months saw about 3.9 million sales, against about 6.5 million a year during COVID. Babcock Ranch has held up better than most. Insurance rates compare well with the rest of Florida, and prices run about 30% below Lakewood Ranch and Wellen Park. Owners who bought after COVID and have to move may face a loss; renting the home out is one option. Greg points to Babcock National and Webb's Reserve, the only two golf communities still being built. Once the builders finish there, those prices have room to rise while another 11,000 homes go up elsewhere.

Watch the full video

Watch the whole show for the slides and the full resale dashboard.

Talk to Team John Garuti

If you are weighing a resale against a new build, or want a realistic number for your home before you buy the next one, we are happy to run the comparison.

Thinking about Babcock Ranch?

Fifteen minutes with John's team: which neighborhood fits, which builder to trust, and what it really costs each month. No pressure, no pitch.

Get a free expert consultationor book a tour

Video transcript

So yeah, we've got a lot of... We didn't get that many questions, but I know a lot of people are going to be watching this live. So if you are watching this live, definitely comment live. And we'll definitely upload a replay of this in the future here, but for anybody who's live, feel free to drop any questions you have about Babcock Ranch real estate. Definitely drop them in the comments.

I mean, this is live on my page and in the Facebook group, so we'd love to hear from you. We'd love to answer your questions. What are your most pressing concerns about Babcock Ranch real estate? And we're going to be talking about tips for buyers, things for buyers to be looking out for, things for sellers. A lot of the town keeps growing, so more people keep buying, more people keep selling, as things should.

The town keeps growing because they just hit a milestone this quarter.

Yeah, we're going to talk about that. Record sales in Q1 here in Babcock Ranch. So that's really cool to see. So yeah, where are we going to kick it off? We also have a really good report I want to share that Greg and I were reviewing earlier. We're going to test Susan to see how good she is when it comes to mortgages. So this report is called the Home Buyers and Sellers Generational Trends. This report's actually put together by the National Association of Realtors. Maybe we should start there and then we can kind of go into some other cool things, some other data that we have.

Yeah, so like a lot of this show, we're going to share a lot of data because we don't want it to just be about our opinions. We want to show you stuff that should really be able to help you, whether you're a buyer or a seller.

Everybody has opinions, but not everybody looks at the data.

That's, yeah, absolutely. So, here's the report. Let's start off here just so you guys have an idea of who we are talking about when we refer to different things inside of this report. We have all the different generations that are in the real estate market today. So, this is going all the way back 100 years. We have the silent generation. That's anybody who was born between 1925 and 1946. So, I'm sure we have some people living in Babcock today that are part of the silent generation, which is really cool.

Next we have older boomers. So, this is anybody born between 1946 and 1954. And then you've got the younger boomers, 1955 to 1964. So, I know for sure we have a lot of people in those age brackets living in Babcock Ranch today. And then we've got the Gen Xers, which Susan and Greg fall into that category.

Hold on. Hold on. Hold on. I'm in a micro generation. It's an Xennial. It's not in there, but that's a good one.

Oh, yeah. Yeah, I don't know why they didn't break apart the Gen X, but I've seen that a lot, how these generations now, things are changing so much that they're shortening the generations or at least putting them in half. Because I fall into the older millennials, which, when you say millennials, sometimes there's a lot of negative connotation about what a millennial is, but believe it or not, I fall into that category.

And the older one.

And then younger millennials, yeah. And then we've got Gen Z now. Believe it or not, these young kids are actually out there buying houses today.

16 years old, apparently, 2011.

I don't know about the 16-year-olds, but yeah, this obviously goes up to anybody born in 1999. I guess that makes you what, 26, 27 years old. So yeah, Gen Z'ers are buying 4% of the real estate around the country today. Which I guess is a good thing, because I've seen a lot of data lately showing how first-time home buyers' age, just because of the way the real estate market is... The biggest challenge in the real estate market today is affordability, and that affordability crunch we're facing right now in the United States is what has pushed the first-time home buyer age up over the last 2 years. And I think the average first-time home buyer now is in their 40s, if I remember correctly.

Late 30s, early 40s.

Yeah, so this is just so you know what we're talking about. But let's go now to our first slide here. So, characteristics of homes purchased. This is pretty interesting, and I think it'll give a lot of good insight. This is good for home buyers and home sellers, because we want to understand why are people buying homes. And this one is glaring right here. This first stat: 43% of recent buyers, the reason they purchased a new home was because they were looking to avoid renovations and problems with plumbing or electricity.

So, that right there shows you a lot about, especially, our market here in Babcock Ranch, and really Southwest Florida, too. I mean, Southwest Florida's loaded with new construction, right? So, this is a big driver for people who are buying homes. They don't want to deal with repairs. And I know there's sellers out there who are like, "Oh, it's only a little fix here, a little fix there." I've seen sellers with attitudes like that. But I'm telling you, Mr. Seller, Mrs. Seller out there, buyers don't want to deal with that.

I didn't know if you could curse or not.

They put a mental value on a new home that I don't know if anybody can actually break down, like what that quantifies. They're willing to put their own money into a new home more so than in some cases buying a home that's not so old with a few things done to it.

Yeah, I think there should be a distinction between new and newer. You know what I'm saying? It might imply newer homes, too, that some resales would fall into, because especially once you leave our market here, an old home could certainly be '50s, '70s, whatever. So I wonder if this means a newer home.

It's also crazy to think that we're almost coming up on 10 years since the first home was built in Babcock Ranch.

Yeah, I think this really refers to why did somebody buy a new construction home versus a resale. So, I think the big thing I would tell sellers here right now is it's probably wise to do an inspection before you put your house on the market. And if you don't want to do that, you better be willing to negotiate when the buyer comes back to you and says, "I would like these repairs done," or "I would like credit so I can go ahead and do these repairs." But I know one thing: it is always cheaper for you, the seller, to do those repairs ahead of time than it is to negotiate. Because again, the buyers are factoring in, I've got to do this work. I've got to come out of cash now rather than just be tying this all up into my mortgage.

And I just had a deal fall apart over what we probably could have negotiated down to $500 of repairs. So if you're a seller in this market, if you're not willing to do repairs, then you're probably going to get caught in a bind here. Once you go under contract, you could easily lose your contract, which in this market, that's scary, because finding buyers for the resales right now is more challenging than it is...

Than if you went pending and then all of a sudden you're not. The first question they're going to be asking is, why is it back on the market?

Yeah, so I think that's my big takeaway for sellers. Your house has got to be good. Your house has to be in tip-top shape, and if buyers find stuff that they don't like, you've got to be ready to deal with that, one way or the other.

Whereas as a seller's agent, if you have an inspection report already done, then you have your leverage and your ammunition to go back against anybody that may come up with a BS report.

Yep. That's a great point too.

And then also you might avoid the lowball offers, because something is visually wrong right from the start.

Yes, also a really good point. Curb appeal is a big deal right now. When people see stuff, they start worrying. Again, you don't want them to build this whole attitude in their mind that they're going to have to buy this house and then do all this work.

People are already aware of all of these new architectural inspections. That's just something added on top of that. Obviously unique to our market, but certainly important.

Right. This is the Babcock real estate show?

Oh, yeah.

So, another stat that's really cool, too. 76% of all homes purchased are detached single-family homes. So, that is the most common among all generations, but those older generations, they do like those duplex condos. We've got plenty of condos on the golf courses here, and the duplexes, really, that's the same thing as a villa. So I think I've kind of seen that here in Babcock myself. A lot of the houses that I know we've sold in neighborhoods like the Preserve or Palmetto Landing that have lots of villas, in general we are selling to more retirees, people that age. Not to say that other generations aren't buying those units either.

Last one here. This one's really interesting, because this is a big trend I have noticed. This says heating and cooling costs and windows, doors, siding were the most important environmental features for recent home buyers. And I think the way I kind of correlate this to Babcock Ranch is I've seen huge challenges selling houses with non-impact glass. And if you don't have impact glass in your house, I just promise you, if you're going to sell it, you'll probably sell it for less than a similar house with similar beds and bathrooms, with similar square footage, for less than a house with impact glass.

More upgrades. With more upgrades inside the house, too. If it doesn't have impact glass, that's kind of one of the first non-negotiables I've seen.

Yep. And I think it's a big... we all know, does that make your house any less strong at the end of the day? No. Your house is still going to be fine in the event of a hurricane with your shutters up. But yeah, it's a perceived value. I've noticed this big time, and I think what's changed is that all the builders, for the most part... except now there's two new neighborhoods that don't have impact glass, which is shocking to me that those builders did not decide to add them.

And we saw a major shift in that after Hurricane Ian, correct?

Yes, well, we know during COVID it was really hard to get impact glass. And then after...

They were adding it as an option or an upgrade to attach more money on, because at that time the market was hot, so they could make more money by offering them as an option or an upgrade. And then as it kind of leveled out, then they just made it standard for all.

Well, it was a supply chain issue for many years, for a good two years. The builders couldn't even get it. So yeah, there was that period of time where no houses had them, and now almost every new construction house you buy nowadays has impact glass.

The other thing I want to point out here too that we were going over is that a typical home that is purchased is typically around 1,900 to 2,000 square feet, three bedrooms, two bath. I mean, how many homes in Babcock Ranch fit that description? How many homes that fit that description are people trying to sell?

So the other thing I like to tell people is, just because you have a Sylvester or you have a Charlotte or whatever floor plan you have, somebody coming in on the resale market isn't looking for a Charlotte or a Mol Ryan, I mean, a Kel Sweetwater. They're looking for a four bed or a three bed or a three with den. They're just looking for certain criteria, and they don't really care what the floor plan is, so they just go off of cost per square foot for the most part. And so, there's so much competition in Babcock Ranch in that range between 1,800 and 2,100 square feet, three bed with a den, four bedroom, two or three bath. There's so much competition for that home in Babcock compared to something like a five-bedroom, four-bath.

Yeah, I think when you are pricing out your home or trying to figure out a list price, you do have to consider what is the supply and demand for that size of a home.

Do you want to be the comp that everybody uses to get their home sold, or do you want to be the house that sells because they used every other comp?

Yep, exactly. So, getting a little deeper into this. Why are people buying new homes? So, the people who bought new homes, again, we just told you 43% don't want to deal with renovations or plumbing or electricity. 22% of them, it's that ability to choose and customize design features, which we know a lot of builders offer here in Babcock Ranch to varying degrees. And then this one right here. This is phase two of Babcock Ranch: amenities of new home construction communities. That's a big thing.

I don't think this is an issue right now in Babcock Ranch. It is around the country. We still have some pockets of real estate throughout the United States where there is very low inventory. And obviously Babcock, we get this bump a little too with all our sustainability, smart home features, living off mainly solar power here. So I think that's a big draw.

But then look at the previously owned home. The number one thing is better overall value.

Yeah, so this right here is what sellers... These first two right here are for sellers. Why are people buying previously owned homes? Because they're seeing better overall value or better price. So what does that mean? Unless you've got a house made out of gold... The saying we use is you either got a deal or you have a diamond. And you've got to be objective with yourself and say, "Do I have a deal or a diamond?" And if I don't have a diamond, well, then, honestly, in this market, guys, it's really going to boil down to price at the end of the day. That value comes from the price in this market for listings.

Regardless of built-in cabinets.

Yeah, regardless of built-in cabinets, anything else that you might have done. If the price is way off, a buyer is going to see that from the beginning.

Right. But talking about value, we're talking about things like, again, people get a mortgage. Do they really want to pay money now out of their pocket for a fence, for custom closets, for maybe a pool, those types of things? So a lot of homes that are on the resale have all those built-ins, fans. Some of these builders don't even have shades. I mean, we put in plantation shutters that were over $10,000 just for that. So a lot of, especially first-time home buyers, are limited in their cash. So buying a resale that has these things built in already is where I see some of that value.

The resale is $100,000 overpriced.

So even water systems and things. What did you say about $100,000?

No, I'm just saying even if the resale home is $100,000 overpriced, they're still not going to touch it, though.

No, of course not. They have to see the value. It has to make sense for the price, but sometimes people don't have that extra $30,000 to put into a house.

So, let's go on now and share some stuff on mortgages. Now we get to test Susan. She didn't even know we're doing this, so we're going to put her...

You just put me on the spot.

No, it's nothing bad, but here's some interesting stats, too. So, how many people are financing their home purchase nowadays? What would you have guessed?

What would I have guessed? How many people are financing their homes?

Yeah, so based on this report, in the last year about 74% of people are financing their home purchase.

I was going to say 70. I said 70, yeah. That's about right.

So again, I think that is something else to consider in general, is that one out of four buyers are coming in with cash or are going to come with cash in general. Now, I think when you look at Babcock, you're going to see different amounts of cash buyers, like on the golf course, and it also depends on the unit and the price point. You go to the golf course, people buying those condos, the terrace condos and veranda condos that are in the 200s and 300s, you're going to get a lot of cash buyers on those. But I would say in general on the single-family homes, the majority of stuff we do on single-family homes is usually a mortgage buyer.

Right now, a lot of times they have some type of incentive, I guess, closing costs, buy down, something tied to the deal to lower their money going in.

The working class also does it strategically so that they can write off their mortgages and stuff like that, too. Some of those people, especially in those 46 to 60 or even the 36 category, are doing that for financial reasons.

Sure. Absolutely. And I think what I'm seeing, too, and Greg, you can share your experience: right now, when we do listings and the buyer brings a mortgage, they are asking for closing cost incentives. It doesn't matter what price we wind up at. Most buyers are asking for...

...of the time, but it is very popular.

Yeah. Well, again, I think that's where you've got to really look and understand what you're netting as a seller and not be so focused on, oh, I'm giving this person another 10 grand to buy down their rate. Because guess what? The buyers are going to ask for it. That's what they're doing in this market, and that's one way they can offset this affordability crunch we're experiencing in real estate right now.

And unfortunately, all the builders are doing it, too. Whether it's someone only doing a $10,000 give back, or I know last month Horton was paying for all the closing costs. I know Lennar will maneuver their numbers around to make the mixture right so you have less money out of pocket up front. All the builders are already doing it. It's just something else that the buyers are looking at. They're like, well, if I'm going to buy a resale, I want you to pay some of my costs.

What, of the mortgages you're doing in town, Susan, are you typically seeing that buyers are asking for?

Yeah, so when it comes to new construction, they really need to get a lot of closing costs, because those are a lot higher than resale. And the builders are really working with the clients to make that happen. So that's really nice, kind of a change we've seen over the last few years. As far as cash buyers, I have a tip for them. So, some people that are looking for a small mortgage, let's say they're not sure if they really want to pay for their house in cash. They can, but maybe it would be good to have a small mortgage of 100,000. It might not be a bad idea to buy that in cash so that you get that negotiating power of cash, and then come to us right after. And we will do what's called delayed financing. If you paid cash for the house, you can get some of that cash back. So, let's say you just want $100,000, just for security's sake, or maybe to have something to write off on your taxes. Go get in with that big negotiating power of a cash buyer, and then contact us right after and take a little bit of a loan and recoup some of that money.

Great idea, yeah. I think cash is king on resales in here. For builders, the only time cash makes a difference is when you can do a quick close and that manager and that builder wants an extra closing in that month. That's when you can leverage cash with new construction. Otherwise, you're buying a house that's 3 months out and you say cash, and they don't give a... That's not going to move the needle for them.

This is another interesting slide. So, the median percentage people are financing nowadays is 81%. Did you think it was that number, Susan?

I don't know if I would have put that. I mean, I know a lot of people like to put 20% down. Obviously, that's an average of the 96.5s, which are extremely common for FHA loans. 95% is really common.

Well, you're seeing that with the younger audience, right? They're financing more of the home, and as people get older and grow their wealth, they're doing less.

For sure. And a funny tip here: at 85%, the rates actually get a tiny bit better than at 80%. So it's kind of a strange thing, but I would say the best rates are starting at 75% or lower. But again, we're being very minuscule, details between the two.

Yeah. So, that's interesting that the average is 81%. And this kind of just follows up: median percent down, it's just the opposite of the slide.

All right, two more slides and then we'll get into some Babcock numbers. Oh man, we've already gone 28 minutes. See, we just start talking and then next thing you know, here we are. Well, I wanted to ask you this, Susan. So, reasons mortgage lenders reject buyer applications. Number one reason...

Debt to income.

Yeah. Debt to income ratio. So, what are lenders looking for right now? Explain debt to income ratio to people who don't fully understand this.

Sure. So, debt to income ratio, first of all, in mortgage lending, we typically have two debt ratios. We have a front end and a back end. The front end ratio is your principal, interest, taxes, insurance, homeowners association. The back end is all those things plus your monthly recurring costs, like your car payment and your minimum monthly payments. So, when they only have one ratio, we typically assume it's the back end that they're referring to. For example, FHA, you can go up to 56.9. VA, we recently did a VA loan where a client had a 78% back-end ratio, because VA doesn't have specific maximums. They use residual income, which is a whole other class in and of itself. But conventional loans are maxed out at around 50%. So, that's pretty much what you're looking at for debt-to-income ratio. Those are high ratios. But I am seeing high ratios these days, especially for first-time home buyers wanting houses. They are really getting in there pretty high. Ideally, in a perfect world, it would be nice if you were to buy a house... where would you be comfortable? I think it would be nice to be less than 45% for sure.

I would sit on a desert island by myself. That's where I'd be comfortable.

Also, sometimes I have people that tell me what their debt ratio is, but they don't realize that the debt ratio is based on the new loan, not your current loan, and it's your gross income, unless you're self-employed and there's a specific mortgage calculation for that depending on the program. So it's quite complicated. Try not to figure it out yourself, please. Happy to help you with that.

There you go. Don't figure it out on your own. Don't try this at home.

This is an interesting one, too. The majority of America still thinks that buying a home is a good financial investment, and only about 5% still think it's not a good financial investment. I think it can be a good financial investment when you're in the property long enough. I think that's the biggest challenge: people buying properties and then selling a year or two later. Obviously a lot of people who bought here after COVID have lost a lot of equity, and that's a big challenge right now. A lot of those people that have to move... unfortunately, we've worked with a lot of sellers that had to take big losses on their equity, which is unfortunate. But I think this is something you've got to understand and be ready to deal with if you do have to move. Luckily, a lot of our clients are listening to us and not moving, because it's too much for them to bear financially.

And I think two words ago in there, not a good financial investment or a good financial investment, we're talking good long-term, right? So, it takes a little bit of time. We were so used to buying a house and having it be worth 30,000, 50,000 more in a year or two. Those are unrealistic. But if you look at real estate overall, it's definitely an upward trend overall. So that's where it gets tough, like you said, the people that are forced to move. But if they're forced to move and they have some really good rates, renting is an option.

And that's what we did. We kept our 2.25 interest rate and rented that house out, and that'll be a part of our financial portfolio for the future.

All right. So, that's that on the generational report. If anybody is interested in this report, just give me a message on Facebook. Happy to send this over to you. So, now let's talk about the market. So, this is the Babcock Ranch real estate market, but we are focusing on resales only here. This does not include new construction, because I think you really have to look at...

It's very tough to do new construction here in Babcock Ranch, just because some of the numbers are manipulated and it's skewed. We just know there were 390-some homes sold in quarter one.

Right. Yeah, and the data on it, obviously, there's a lot of variables. One being that the builders don't put the majority of the houses that they sell inside the MLS. It would be one thing if every single sale that they closed in Babcock Ranch did get entered into the MLS, but that's not the case. So, when you look at this stuff, I kind of look at it like, all right, let's analyze the resale market and then consider what we've got to go up against with new construction. But right now, there are 100 total active properties listed in Babcock Ranch on the resale market. So, that's actually a very, very small percentage, because I think there's over 5,500 finished properties in Babcock Ranch, and I always hear people say, "Oh my gosh, why is there so much for sale on the resale market?" And it really isn't that much for sale at the end of the day, actually.

And these are single-family homes, or does this include villas and condos?

That is total. So, my little cute dashboard here breaks that up. Single-family, there's 39 active. There's actually 37 villas. Wow, I didn't even realize there's that many. And then condos. There's usually always a fair amount of condos for sale on the golf courses. But let's start with single-family. Wow, I'm kind of surprised that the median sold prices are this high.

Yeah, that's high.

But this is where I think a lot of sellers, you've got to really be cautious about looking at data. Because when you go into sold price range distribution, look at this on single-family homes. This is really cool. There is only one home in the 3 to 400k range, six in the four to five, four in the five to 600k range, eight in the six to 700k range, four in the seven to 800k range, and then three over 800,000. So, that shows you the higher-end home resales, those, going back to that report, are the ones that typically have charm and character that buyers are willing to spend money on. But when you get into these lower ranges, which the builders have... when you talk about three to 400,000, there is so much on the market on the new construction market right now. My god.

Probably 40 alone in Tucker's Cove you can go do, and then you've got Sabal Glen, and then you've got Crescent Lakes, and then you've got Toll Brothers at Weddington.

What new construction neighborhood doesn't have a house between three and 400,000? Maybe just the Regency, in terms of new construction. But we have a villa listed in the Regency that's in that price range.

On the flip side though, there's a lot more people that will qualify for 400,000 than the higher end, too.

Yeah. And I think this is also something too now: 94 units sold here in the last 120 days. For anyone asking, this is over the past 120 days. How many sold, you said? 390 sold new construction homes? And that was in the first quarter?

Yeah.

So, you can still see, this is over 4 months, but there's still that huge gap. Buyers coming in today, the majority of them are still going to the new construction homes.

But I think we broke it down, and it still holds true, that like 90% of people that are buying a house in Babcock Ranch are choosing new construction, and of that 90%, like 60% of them don't even have a realtor, and they're just walking right into a builder's office. So, you're not even getting 60% of the market looking at your house on market reports and listing alerts. No one's even seeing your house. You only got a small piece of the pie here, people that actually have realtors, when the overwhelming majority just walk right into a building.

Yeah, that's real. I didn't even think about that. That's a great point. This is also really interesting here, too, going on with single family. Look at this, guys. Terminated and expired. That's 25. Almost one out of three homes that go on the market today in Babcock Ranch are coming off the market.

Well, that has something to do with price.

Most likely it's a price issue, yeah.

And I really encourage sellers to reach out to a mortgage person to find out what they need to sell their house for, just to make sure it makes sense. They can get the numbers that they need, because you never know, you might be able to take a lower price and just put a little less money down and make it work.

You're buying a new house on the low anyways. We're in a low right now, right? So if you're selling low, you're probably buying low also. It's relative.

Right. Yeah, and I would say a big thing I've seen is I have seen a lot of people go buy a house first. People moving across town, they found a new neighborhood, a new house that they like more. They go make the purchase and then they come to the realtor and say, "Okay, I need to sell my house now." And then when we start breaking it down, it's like, "Oh, this might not work." And I've seen people lose their deposits over stuff like this. So I would tell you, if you're going to buy another house, you need to talk to the realtor first about what you can realistically sell your house for before you go to that builder and buy that next house. Because man, I've seen a lot of people lose out on their deposits, and it's scary to see. It's unfortunate.

So, villas, though. The villas seem to be doing pretty good, but again...

And look at list to price ratio.

Yeah, and I'm looking at this, though, and I think something's off here. Trails Edge villas aren't selling for $400,000.

So, back to the single family home real quick. And look at that list to sale ratio. And that probably has a few price reductions prior to that as well. You're losing 5% on any price reduction you chase down on the market anyway. So, why not price it where it's going to sell, so you don't lose that money with all of these different adjustments? If you list for 480 and take, I don't know, 415, maybe you should have been at 450. You could have got 440 for 30.

Yeah, and condos here. This looks correct. We've got Willowgreen. This is including coach homes. So, Willowgreen, Webb's, Babcock National. I'd also tell people, really understand days on market. I had a client recently who was pissed their house wasn't sold after a month. I'm like, guys, you look at the average across all properties, the days on market is like 75 days.

There's always going to be that one-off, too, right? Some houses, every once in a while you get something that lasted a day, five days, but that's not typical. So you prepare yourself for the average.

That, and there's a lot of variables that can make a house sell, variables that are out of everybody's control. For example, one of the agents on my team was working with a buyer recently and they had a big family. They moved into town, or they sold their house, they had to have a house here right away for work and to get their kids acclimated for next school year, mainly for work though. So they're like, we've got to be there, and there was one big house on the market that they saw and they just pulled the trigger and paid full price. And we were like, you could probably pay less for this house, but they didn't care. They were like, we need to lock this house in. We can't mess around. We've got to be there.

So sometimes you never know the scenarios of what's going on with buyers at times, because you see some houses that sell for way more than you thought it should go for, and then we see lots of houses where we're like, damn, how did that house not get more? And again, there's so many different factors that go into this. This is not an exact science. It's never been an exact science. It never will be, because there's so many things that are out of our control.

Yeah. I think there was a Washingtonia that sold in a day recently. Well, that's because there are none. If there were 10 of them available, that might be a different story. But when you're the only one, that's when it's time to strike. But if there's 20 other houses similar to yours, you need strategy.

That's where, yeah, looking at the supply and demand of your model, similar models, what do the builders have, right? There are points in time where there are good times to strike. And I think for sellers, you really want an agent that really understands and keeps track of the new construction, because ultimately that's who you're going up against. Whether you like it or not, Kitson is your competitor, and Pulte and Lennar and DR Horton, those are your competitors. And all the other people that are listed in town, too. But if you're only considering the resale market and not considering what you have to compete against new construction-wise, I think you're setting yourself up for failure.

And also, if your house is different. Like you said, that's a big thing. Only Washingtonia, or only Majestica in Tucker's, or only... things like that for resale, because some of those, it takes time to build those models. So it's very interesting, and that's why I think a lot of the higher prices might be bigger homes that we're seeing.

Yeah, that's what the data is showing, right? These higher priced homes, more of those are selling than the smaller homes.

I guess my home's going on the market, John.

Oh, boy.

Just kidding.

So, I guess that's really it. I've got to revisit that villa report. I don't like how that came out.

Babcock is great.

Yeah. I think another big thing to let people in this market know: we've had 3 years in a row now of the worst real estate sales around the country. This has been 3 years in a row of the worst real estate sales in the last 50 years. So when you do rolling 12-month looks at how many sales there were in this country, right now, the last 12 months there was about 3.9 million home sales across the United States. So we're going on 3 years in a row now of being right at this 4 million rolling average number. That is extremely low. And again, that shows you we have this really tough affordability crisis in America. But people are always asking me, "Well, when are we going to get out of this?" Even normal markets... during COVID, I mean, COVID was a crazy market, but just to show you, in COVID, those years, we sold about 6 and 1/2 million homes across the country. That's 2 and 1/2 million more home sales going on on a 12-month basis than today. So that just shows you how much the market has changed here over the last couple years.

And it's incredible how well Babcock has been doing through that. Because if you go back to the affordability, it's not just about interest rates, right? When you're in Florida, you've got to talk about insurance rates. And luckily, in comparison to other places in Florida, Babcock has great insurance rates. That does drive people here. They do feel safer from hurricanes and things like that. And obviously it's a great place to raise a family. So I think all those things have helped Babcock remain strong.

And I also feel that when people are looking from a distance, as most people do with Florida real estate, they're looking at Lakewood, they're looking at Wellen, they're looking at the East Coast, they're looking at Babcock. And I feel Babcock has grown because Babcock is still like 30% cheaper than Lakewood Ranch and Wellen Park, and much, much cheaper than Miami or the Palm Beaches. So we have the affordability in Babcock Ranch due to the builders, which is why they're the competition, unfortunately, for anybody trying to sell their home. And the builder can do whatever the builder wants to do. They've got deep pockets.

And we're becoming less and less out there, right? Because we're getting so much here, between restaurants and gas stations being built in the future, and just having everything you need right here. It's all here. So it doesn't seem as far out there as it used to when we didn't have a Publix. That's when I lived here. We didn't have any of that stuff. So it's amazing to see the growth.

Back in the day I used to walk in the snow to Publix when I first moved to Babcock Ranch. 6 miles one way. No, but I think there are two communities that are prime for big gains in the very near future, and that's going to be Babcock National or Webb's Reserve, because those are the only two golf communities they're building. So, once they're done building those two neighborhoods, those prices will go up while everything else kind of still sits while they build another 11,000 homes.

I agree. That's where it's at. All those people on the golf courses, just wait a few more years, three, four more years.

And yeah, I agree, too. I'm not seeing any questions, so I guess this is our cue to wrap it up for now. But Susan, Greg, appreciate you guys being on here. And if you are watching the replay...

What's that? Where did you get that beautiful shirt from?

Oh, only available to people who join Team John Garuti.

I don't have one.

Well, you're going to be on Team John Garuti one day. But anybody watching the replay, definitely, once you see this replay and you watch it, drop some questions, too. We'd also love to hear feedback on what we did good and what you'd like to see on future episodes. I think right now the plan's to do this monthly, but hey, if you want more of this, we're happy to do it every other week or maybe even weekly. We don't know, but we'd love to see your feedback. So, please make some comments after you watch our episode. And Susan, Greg, thank you guys again for jumping on and doing this. And everybody out there in Babcock Ranch, we appreciate you all. And we hope to see you on the next version of the Babcock Ranch Real Estate Show.

But if everybody has a bunch of questions, please send them in, because John would love nothing more than to do this every other day. He's not busy enough.

That's true. I like being on camera.

You guys are funny. Well, it was nice getting together and doing this again. It's been a long time.

Definitely. All right, everybody, thank you again. We'll see you next time.