Regency or Alta Key? The two 55+ communities at Babcock Ranch, compared.

The age rule, the monthly cost and what each one includes, on one page. No sales pressure, and we do not work for either builder.

The honest comparison.

They are both 55+, both gated and both inside the same solar-powered town. Almost everything else about them is different, starting with how you own the home.

Side by side
WhatRegencyAlta Key
Builder / operatorToll BrothersHigh Point Living
How you own itYou own the home and the lot (fee simple)You own the home; the homesite is on a 99-year land lease
Age status55+ age-restricted55+ age-restricted
GatedYesYes
Home typesSingle-family homes (Lago and Sol collections) and villas (Terra collection, resale only)Single-story, two-bedroom single-family homes (Pioneer, Oasis, Lighthouse)
Square feet1,529 to 3,3101,590 to 1,648
Starting priceFrom $424,995 (Lago) and $545,995 (Sol) (as of 2026-09-29)From $249,000 (as of 2026-09-14)
Own amenity centerYesYes
Monthly cost structureMonthly HOA to the neighborhood association (gate, amenity center, lawn care)Monthly lifestyle installment to High Point Living for the land lease
Construction statusSelling now, quick move-in homes availableFirst homes complete, released in phases

Regency: 55+ age-restricted community (federal Housing for Older Persons Act). Alta Key: 55+ age-restricted community (federal Housing for Older Persons Act).

Who can live there, exactly.

Under the federal Housing for Older Persons Act, a 55+ community must have at least one resident aged 55 or older in at least 80 percent of its occupied homes. Each community then sets its own rules in its recorded documents: the minimum age for a younger spouse or partner, whether adult children can live with you, and how long grandchildren can visit.

We read the recorded documents before you sign, not the brochure. Ask us for the exact rule for the community you are considering and we will send you the page it comes from.

Ask for the recorded rule

Age status, verified

Regency
55+ age-restricted
Alta Key
55+ age-restricted

Regency: tollbrothers.com Regency at Babcock Ranch page ("the only gated 55+ community for active adults within the Babcock Ranch master plan") and babcockranch.com neighborhoods list ("55+ active-adult"), checked 2026-09-29. Alta Key: babcockranch.com neighborhoods list ("55+", "active adults") and John Garuti, 2026-09-11. alta-key.com describes itself as an "Active Adult Community" without publishing the occupancy rule., checked 2026-09-29.

Two different cost structures, not two prices.

A single like-for-like monthly number would mislead you. Regency is fee-simple ownership with an HOA and a CDD. Alta Key is a land lease with a monthly lifestyle installment. Here is how each one adds up.

Regency, Single Family Home - Lago Collection

Monthly HOA
$436 a month
Annual CDD (50' Lot)
$2,404 a year
Together, spread over twelve months
about $636 a month

Open the HOA and CDD calculator

Alta Key

How it is billed
Monthly lifestyle installment to High Point Living for the land lease
Lawn care, shared spaces and community management are handled for you
No HOA dues unless residents choose to form an association
Property tax and homeowner insurance on top; we confirm the CDD and master fee position before you sign

High Point Living sets the monthly lifestyle installment for Alta Key and quotes it per home. We confirm the current figure, and whether the lease covers the Babcock Ranch master association fee and the CDD, before you sign anything.

Worked example

HOA and CDD figures come from our verified fee data for Babcock Ranch. Mortgage, property tax and insurance are not included.

What the CDD actually is

The Community Development District (CDD) assessment funds the roads, utilities and drainage that were built before the homes. It is billed once a year on your property tax bill, not monthly to an HOA. Part of it is ongoing operations and maintenance; the larger part is debt service that is paid off on a fixed schedule, so it is finite and it declines as the bonds are retired.

Starting prices as of: Regency 2026-09-29 (tollbrothers.com); Alta Key 2026-09-14 (High Point Living pricing sheet).

Yours, and the whole Ranch.

Each neighborhood has its own amenity center behind the gate. Both also sit inside Babcock Ranch, a golf-cart-friendly town where Founder's Square, the trails and the lakes belong to every resident.

Inside your gate

Private amenity center with pool, Fitness center and social room, Pickleball, tennis, bocce and shuffleboard, Putting green and community garden, Dog park, fishing pond and trails.

  • regency amenities
  • regency amenities
  • regency amenities
  • regency amenities
  • regency amenities
  • regency amenities
  • regency amenities
  • regency amenities
  • regency amenities
  • regency amenities
  • regency amenities
  • regency amenities
  • regency amenities
  • regency amenities
  • regency amenities
  • regency amenities
  • regency amenities
  • regency amenities

Inside your gate

Resort-style pool and clubhouse, Putting green, Pickleball courts, Fire pits and nature trails.

  • Alta Key clubhouse and resort-style pool (rendering)
  • Alta Key site map, homesites, clubhouse and lakes
  • Alta Key model home living and dining area (rendering)
  • Babcock Ranch lookout tower at sunset, minutes from Alta Key
  • Outdoor yoga on the lawn at Babcock Ranch near Alta Key

Across the town

  • Founder's Square — the town square at Babcock Ranch

    Founder's Square

  • Nature trail boardwalk — 50+ miles of trails at Babcock Ranch®

    50+ miles of trails

  • K–12 schools on-site

  • 870-acre solar field

  • Lake Babcock

  • The Hatchery

The questions buyers actually ask us.

Straight answers from a team that lives here and sells here. Nothing below comes from a builder brochure.

Will I be living next to construction for years?

Yes, parts of Babcock Ranch are still being built and will be for some time. Inside Regency and Alta Key the work is phased, so ask us which streets are finished and which are still active before you pick a lot. A completed street with a finished street behind it is the quiet choice.

Can I resell in a town this young?

Resales already happen in every neighborhood at Babcock Ranch, and we handle them. A 55+ home in a gated community with its own amenity center sells to the same buyer pool you are in now. We will show you actual resale activity in the community you are considering, not a projection.

Is the CDD a hidden fee?

No, but it is a real one. It shows up once a year on the property tax bill, and part of it is finite debt that declines over time. We put it into the monthly math above so there is no surprise at closing.

How far is the beach and the airport?

Babcock Ranch is inland, east of Punta Gorda. Southwest Florida International (RSW) and the Gulf beaches are a drive, not a walk. We will give you real door-to-door drive times for the routes you care about rather than a marketing radius.

What about doctors and hospitals?

There are medical offices in and around Babcock Ranch, and full hospitals in Punta Gorda and Fort Myers. Tell us what care you need to be near and we will map real drive times to it.

What happened during Hurricane Ian?

Babcock Ranch kept power through Ian in 2022. The town is built to newer codes on higher ground, with buried utilities and its own solar array and storage. That is the reason many of our 55+ buyers chose it.

John Garuti III, Team John Garuti — eXp Realty®

A local team, no sales pressure.

Team John Garuti has sold more than 600 new homes at Babcock Ranch and holds the most five-star reviews of any team here. Buyers pay nothing; the builder pays us.

Rather talk?

+1 (239) 251-2371 info@babcockranchnewhomes.com

Get floor plans and pricing for Regency and Alta Key

Same form as above. If you already sent it, you are on the list.

Hi John,

It costs you nothing and there is no obligation. We will not spam you or pass your details to anyone, and because we do not work for any builder, you get honest advice on every neighborhood.

Regency and Alta Key FAQ.

Are Regency and Alta Key both 55+ communities?

Yes. Both are listed by Babcock Ranch as 55+ active adult neighborhoods. Regency is built by Toll Brothers and Alta Key by High Point Living. Each community sets its own detailed occupancy rules in its recorded documents, which we read with you before you sign.

What is the 55+ age rule?

Federal law requires at least one resident aged 55 or older in at least 80 percent of occupied homes in a 55+ community. The minimum age for other residents and the visitor policy are set by each community's own documents.

What is a land lease at Alta Key?

You buy and own the home outright. The homesite under it is leased from High Point Living on a 99-year term, paid as a monthly lifestyle installment that also covers lawn care, shared spaces and community management.

What is the CDD fee at Babcock Ranch?

The CDD assessment pays for the roads, utilities and drainage built for the town. It is billed once a year on the property tax bill and part of it is finite debt that declines over time. Our calculator shows the exact figure by community and lot.

Can my grandchildren visit or stay?

Visiting is normal in every 55+ community. How long younger guests can stay is set by each community's recorded rules, and we will send you the exact clause for Regency or Alta Key.

Are pets allowed?

Yes in both communities. Breed and number limits, if any, come from the recorded documents, and we check them for you.

Can I resell a 55+ home at Babcock Ranch?

Yes. Resales happen across Babcock Ranch today and we handle them. The buyer pool for a gated 55+ home with its own amenities is the same one you are in now.

Read the longer article on choosing a 55+ community

Get the floor plans and current pricing for both

Tell us which community you are leaning toward, or say you are not sure yet. We send the plans, real pricing and the fee breakdown, then follow up by phone only if you want us to.

We will text you a code to confirm your number. No spam, ever.

Hi John,

It costs you nothing and there is no obligation. We will not spam you or pass your details to anyone, and because we do not work for any builder, you get honest advice on every neighborhood.

We are committed to the letter and spirit of the Fair Housing Act. Age-qualified communities operate under the federal Housing for Older Persons Act; occupancy rules are set by each community's recorded documents.